New study of IRS data: about 57,000 nonprofits a year lose tax-exempt status after three years without filing. Find your state

Home / Blog / First-time donors

Fundraising · first-time donors

After the first gift: getting first-time donors to give again

By the Ember team · November 12, 2026

GivingTuesday is December 1, and some of that day's gifts will come from names you don't know, people giving to you for the first time. But fewer than one in five first-time donors from 2024 gave to the same nonprofit again in 2025. Here's a plan for the 90 days after that first gift, so more of yours do.

The short version

Thank every first-time donor within 48 hours, then spend the next 90 days showing them the good their gift did. Send a welcome letter, an update with no ask and an invitation to see the work, then ask again at three months. Keep first-time donors on their own list, so you can see who gives a second time.

The second gift is the hard one

The Fundraising Effectiveness Project tracks giving data from more than 15,000 organizations. Its report for the full year 2025 looked at donors who gave to a nonprofit for the first time in 2024. Just 18.9 percent gave to that same nonprofit again in 2025. That's fewer than one in five, and the rate didn't move from the year before.

Donors who gave in 2024 and in at least one earlier year came back at 59.3 percent. So people who have given in two or more years are about three times as likely to give again. The drop happens between the first gift and the second.

The report's advice is to treat the first month after a gift as the start of a relationship. Thank quickly, show what the gift made possible, then follow up in a more personal way. It adds that smaller groups often do this by being close to their donors and knowing them. Here is one way a small team can do that, starting the day the gift comes in. GivingTuesday with a team of two covers the campaign that brings these gifts in.

Your 90 days, step by step

  1. Days 1 and 2: say thank you

    Thank each first-time donor within 48 hours, by name, and say what the gift will do. Send a short email from a real person on the day it arrives. Then call, or send a handwritten note. A receipt isn't a thank-you. Thank every donor within 48 hours has the email to copy, a call script and the list that keeps track.

  2. Week 2: make the letter a welcome

    Every donor should get a letter after the thank-you that names the gift and what it does. For a first-time donor, make that letter a welcome that is about them. Share one photo and one line on what their gift is already doing. Tell them who you are in two sentences. Give them a real person's name and email to write to. Then tell them what they will hear from you, and how often. How to write a donor thank-you letter has a template for a first gift to start from.

    Leave out the ask and the reply envelope. If your year-end appeal or its reminder hasn't gone out yet, take anyone who just gave off that list.

  3. January: one update, with no ask

    Tell them what happened. If your GivingTuesday goal was 60 backpacks, say the day they went out. Share a picture of the table where they were packed. Add one line from someone who got one, with their permission, or a parent's if they are a child. End with thanks, not a button.

    This update is the easiest one to skip, so put it on the calendar now.

  4. February: an invitation to see the work

    Ask them in, not for money. Offer a tour, an open house, a volunteer shift, or a 15-minute call with the person who runs the program. For donors who live far away, a two-minute video from the site works.

    Make it easy to say yes and fine to say no. Some will come. The rest will still see that the door is open.

  5. Around day 90: the second ask

    Early March is about three months after GivingTuesday. Write to each first-time donor on their own, from a person. Start with what their first gift did. Then ask for one clear amount, close to what they gave before, for one clear thing.

    Offer a small monthly gift as a choice, too. The same report suggests smaller groups offer a simple way to give again and again. If someone doesn't give this time, keep them on your updates and ask again later in the year.

Keep first-time donors on their own list

You can't follow up with people you can't find. Set up a list of their own now, before GivingTuesday, then add every first-time donor from that day and the rest of December. A tab in a spreadsheet is enough. If you already keep one list of every gift, copy its first-time rows onto that tab.

For each person, keep:

  • Name, email and mailing address, if you have them
  • The date and amount of the first gift
  • Where it came from, such as GivingTuesday 2026
  • The date you sent each of the five steps above
  • Anything they told you, like why they gave

Look at the list every two weeks and ask one question: who is due a step? Then, at the end of 2027, count how many of your 2026 first-time donors gave again in 2027. That is your first-time retention rate, and it is the number to beat the next year. Donor retention and stewardship covers how to treat new, repeat and lapsed donors a little differently.

Ember Giving keeps each donor's giving history from the gifts you record, holds every gift on a needs-a-thank-you list until its donor is thanked, and flags who's gone quiet. Sign up for Ember Giving before GivingTuesday. Free if your budget is under $50K a year, with no credit card.

If you only have an hour at a time

A team of two can do this. Block one hour on the calendar now for each step: early December, the second week of December, January, February and early March. Draft the January update and the February invitation in December, while GivingTuesday is fresh. Fill in the January details once they happen, then schedule what you can.

Keep each note short, true and about the good their gift did. None of them needs a designer. So which of those five hours goes on your calendar first?

The Ember tool for this

Ember Giving

Record each gift, see who still needs a thank-you, and get a draft you send from your own email. Free under a $50K budget. Unlimited users on every tier.

Sources: Fundraising Effectiveness Project, a joint project of the Association of Fundraising Professionals Foundation for Philanthropy and GivingTuesday (fepreports.org): 2025 Q4 FEP Report, covering the full year 2025, its Retention Rate by Donor Type and its Terminology page; GivingTuesday.org for the 2026 date. All read 24 September 2026. The backpacks in the examples are made up to show the format.

Common questions

What is a good retention rate for first-time donors?

The Fundraising Effectiveness Project looked at more than 15,000 organizations. Of donors who gave to a nonprofit for the first time in 2024, 18.9 percent gave to it again in 2025. Repeat donors, who gave in 2024 and an earlier year, came back at 59.3 percent. For you, a good rate is one that beats last year's. Count it the same way each year so you can compare.

When should you ask a first-time donor for a second gift?

About three months after the first gift, once they have seen what it did. Before then, thank them within 48 hours and send a welcome letter about their gift. Share one update with no ask, and invite them to see the work. Then ask in a personal note for one clear amount, close to their first gift.

How do you get first-time donors to give again?

Treat the first gift as a start. Thank each donor by name within 48 hours. Over the next 90 days, send a welcome letter that shows what the gift did. Then send one update with no ask, and invite them to visit or volunteer. Keep first-time donors on a list of their own. About three months in, ask for a second gift in a personal note.

Get More Good, Ember's newsletter

Tested tools and simple ideas that give your team time back for the work that matters.

Unsubscribe anytime. See past issues. Privacy policy

Your privacy choices

We use cookies to improve this site and our ads. Analytics cookies show us how the site is used. Ad cookies (Google, Meta) measure our ads and help show them to people likely to find Ember useful.

We honor Global Privacy Control automatically: if your browser sends it, ad cookies stay off.

Read our privacy policy